When it comes to steam cleaning vs shampooing carpet, there is a lot of debate about which method is the best way to get a really clean carpet.
Each of these methods has its own advantages and disadvantages. When you’re trying to choose the right one for your home, you’ll want to consider some different factors.
In this blog post, we’ll be taking a closer look at those factors and the pros and cons of both steam cleaning carpets and carpet shampooing.
Our goal is to help you decide which method is best for your needs.
The Basics of Steam Cleaning vs Shampooing Carpet
Keeping carpets clean is a must for homeowners. Carpet gets dirty so easily. To have a healthy and clean home, especially for allergy sufferers, we have to maintain them.
Choosing the right regular cleaning method can be confusing.
Your best option would be to have your carpets cleaned by professional carpet cleaners. However, we understand you probably want clean carpets without using carpet cleaning services.
Therefore, the two most popular DIY methods are shampooing and steam cleaning. These DIY methods are great for cleaning carpets on a regular basis.
Shampooing carpets involves applying a cleaning agent, or shampoo, to the carpet. The solution is worked into the fibers with a cleaning machine that has a brush. This method uses a lot of water to help remove stuck and loose dirt, dust, and stains from the carpet.
Once the shampoo has been applied and agitated with a brush, the final step is for the water and dirt to be vacuumed by the machine from the carpet.
Steam cleaning, on the other hand, uses a machine that sprays hot water onto the carpet. A steam cleaning machine with hot water penetrates the fibers of the carpet to loosen dirt and stains. Then the machine sucks up the water and dirt with a wet vacuum.
Both methods are effective in removing dirt, stains, and grime from carpets and have a powerful vacuum for removing the water as it cleans.
Keep in mind, there are a few differences between the two methods that should be considered.
Differences Between Steam Cleaning vs Shampooing Carpet
The shampooing method uses more water and chemicals than steam cleaning. This means that carpets can take longer to dry and can be left with a chemical residue.
The chemical residue might attract dirt and make the carpet look dirty again in a shorter time frame.
Typically, a carpet cleaning machine will come with a carpet cleaning solution to get you started.
The steam cleaning process is a more natural approach that does not use any chemicals or detergents. It uses heat for disinfecting and it’s considered to be a safer cleaning option for pets and children.
Steam cleaning works well for removing deeply embedded dirt and stains, and shampooing may be a better option for mild stains and odors.
You’ll have to consider the type of stain and level of dirt on your carpet when deciding on which method to use.
The Pros and Cons of Steam Cleaning vs Shampooing Carpet
Shampooing and steam cleaning are both effective methods for cleaning carpets. However, they each come with their own set of pros and cons.
- A great option for heavily soiled carpets.
- It uses a high concentration of cleaning solution that can penetrate deep into the fibers and lift dirt and stains.
- Typically cheaper than steam cleaning and can be done at home with rental machines.
- The solution used in shampooing usually includes a built-in conditioner that leaves carpets feeling soft and plush.
- Can leave behind a soapy residue if not rinsed thoroughly. This residue can attract more dirt and lead to a re-soiling of the carpet.
- The process can take longer than steam cleaning because it will take longer to dry. This can be inconvenient if you need to use the room soon after cleaning.
Steam Cleaning Pros:
- A deep cleaning method that uses hot water to penetrate deep into the carpet fibers and lift dirt and stains.
- Doesn’t use any chemicals or soaps, making it a great option for those who are sensitive to strong cleaning solutions.
- Very effective at removing allergens and bacteria that can accumulate in carpets over time.
Steam Cleaning Cons:
- The cost of steam cleaning can be higher than shampooing, especially if you hire a professional company to do the job.
- The process of steam cleaning can be more time-consuming as the machine needs to be set up, and it can take longer to clean the carpet thoroughly.
Overall, both shampooing and steam cleaning have their advantages and disadvantages.
The best method for you will depend on the level of soiling in your carpets and your budget.
For heavily soiled carpets, shampooing may be the better option, while for regular maintenance and deep cleaning, steam cleaning is usually the better choice.
Which Method is Better for Different Types of Stains?
When it comes to cleaning your carpets, it’s important to consider the type of stain you’re dealing. This is so you can determine the best method for cleaning.
Let’s take a look at which method is better for different types of stains.
For general dirt and grime, both steam cleaning and shampooing can effectively clean your carpets.
Steam cleaning may be more effective for deeply embedded dirt and stains. This is because the hot water and steam can penetrate deep into the fibers of the carpet.
For deep stains like pet stains, like urine and feces, steam cleaning is usually the preferred method.
The high temperature of the steam can help to kill bacteria and neutralize odors of heavy stains. This way, your carpets are left fresh and clean.
Shampooing may not be as effective in completely removing the odor from pet stains, and sometimes the shampoo solution makes the smells worse.
For oil-based stains, like grease or food stains, shampooing may be the better option. The shampoo solution can effectively break down and remove these types of stains; whereas steam cleaning may not be as effective.
Both methods can potentially damage certain types of carpets, so you should check the manufacturer’s recommendations before choosing a cleaning method.
You’ll want to test several small areas of your carpet somewhere out of plain sight to be sure it’s not going to damage it.
Also, some carpets may require specialized cleaning methods, so it’s always best to consult a professional if you’re unsure.
Which Method is Better for Different Types of Carpets
When it comes to cleaning carpets, not all methods are created equal. Depending on the type of carpet you have, one cleaning method may work better than the other.
Let’s take a look at which method is better for different types of carpets.
Low-pile carpets are made with short fibers and are usually used in high foot traffic areas like hallways and offices. These types of carpets are durable and easy to clean. Steam cleaning is a good option for low-pile carpets, because it can penetrate deep into the fibers to remove dirt and grime.
High-pile carpets are made with longer fibers and are usually used in bedrooms and living areas. These types of carpets are soft and cozy but can be more challenging to clean. Shampooing is a better option for high-pile carpets, because it can clean the surface well without damaging the fibers.
Wool carpets are a natural fiber and are usually more delicate than synthetic carpets. These carpets require special care to avoid damaging them, so you’ll want to use a cleaning method that is gentle. Steam cleaning is a better option for wool carpets, because it doesn’t involve any harsh chemicals that could harm the fibers.
Berber carpets are a type of looped carpet that is made with continuous carpet fibers. These types of carpets are durable and stain-resistant. They aren’t technically supposed to be cleaned with water, but many people say it won’t hurt it as long as you suck up the majority of the water with the cleaner. This way, it’s able to dry well quickly.
Steam cleaning is a good option for Berber carpets, because it can work well to clean the fibers without causing damage. You might also want to use fans to speed up the drying process for these types of carpets, but it can really be helpful with all types.
In the end, the best method for cleaning your carpets depends on your specific needs.
After weighing the pros and cons of both methods, it’s clear that both steam cleaning and shampooing have their advantages and disadvantages.
Consider your type of carpet, how dirty your carpet is, and whether or not you want to use a chemical solution on your carpet to determine the best approach for your home.
Before you go, here are more posts you’ll enjoy: