Are you working on your landscape and wondering, “Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?”.

We’re answering that question and giving you all the info on prepping your landscape beds! 

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

Mulch is a great way to improve the look of your flower beds and protect your plants from weeds.

Below we are sharing what the experts recommend and how to make sure you get the most out of your mulch. Let’s dive in!

What is Landscape Fabric?

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

Landscape fabric, also known as weed fabric, is a porous material used in gardening and landscaping to control weed growth and soil erosion.

It’s made from synthetic materials like polyester or polypropylene, and is usually sold in rolls.

A landscape fabric comes in varying thicknesses and textures. It’s designed to allow water and air to penetrate through while blocking sunlight and preventing weeds from sprouting.

It may seem like a good solution for weed control and moisture retention, but using landscape fabric under mulch has its drawbacks.

Before deciding to use landscape fabric, make sure you look at all the benefits and drawbacks. Furthermore, know there are alternative options that might be better suited for your garden needs.

What is Mulch?

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

This might seem like a silly question. Mulch is pretty well known. But it actually refers to a wider variety of materials than many people know.

Mulch is any material used to cover the soil surface in a garden or landscape.

It can be made from any organic or inorganic materials, like wood chips, pine needles, bark, leaves, grass clippings, rocks, gravel, or rubber.

Mulch serves a number of important functions in the garden, such as:

  • Moisture retention: Mulch helps to keep the soil moist by reducing water loss from evaporation. This is especially important during hot, dry weather when plants are more susceptible to water stress.
  • Weed suppression: Mulch helps to smother weeds by blocking their access to light and preventing them from germinating and growing.
  • Temperature regulation: Mulch helps to keep the soil temperature more stable by insulating it from extreme heat or cold.
  • Soil improvement: As mulch breaks down over time, it adds organic matter to the soil, which helps to improve its structure and fertility.

Overall, mulch can be a useful tool for anyone who wants to improve the health and productivity of their plants and reduce the amount of maintenance time and effort.

Is it always necessary or helpful to use landscape fabric under mulch? That’s what we’ll explore in the following sections.

Benefits of Landscape Fabric Under Mulch

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

Weed barrier fabric provides a range of benefits that make it an attractive option for maintaining a healthy and thriving garden.

Landscape fabric and a properly applied layer of mulch can:

1. Suppresses Weeds

As mentioned above, garden fabric helps prevent weeds. The use of landscape fabric saves time and effort in weed control, giving you more time to enjoy your garden. Plus, it can help by eliminating the need for weed killers. 

2. Retains Moisture

Landscape fabric also helps to retain moisture in the soil by preventing it from evaporating too quickly from your flower gardens. This can be particularly important in hot and dry climates, where water conservation is crucial.

3. Improves Soil Health

By blocking sunlight and preventing weed growth, landscape fabric helps to keep the soil loose and aerated. This allows air, water, and nutrients to penetrate the top layer of soil and promote healthy plant growth. This can be really helpful in a vegetable garden.

4. Reduces Erosion

Another benefit of weed control fabric is that it helps to prevent soil erosion by keeping the mulch in place. This is especially important on steep slopes and areas prone to heavy rain or a combination of both.

5. Enhances Aesthetics

Landscape fabric helps to create a clean and tidy look in your garden. By preventing weeds from growing, it gives your garden a polished and professional appearance.

These are all appealing to gardeners or homeowners who just want beautiful landscaping. But you should also consider the drawbacks and alternative options before making a final decision.

Drawbacks of Landscape Fabric Under Mulch

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

While there are certainly benefits to using landscape fabric under mulch, there are also some significant drawbacks to consider. Here are a few:

1. Reduced Nutrient Availability

Landscape fabric can restrict the flow of nutrients from the soil to your plants, which can lead to stunted growth and reduced health.

2. Drainage Issues

Depending on the type of soil and the amount of rainfall your area gets, landscape fabric can lead to drainage issues. Water can accumulate on top of the fabric, causing root rot and other problems with the root systems of your plants.

3. Cost 

Landscape fabric isn’t cheap, and it may not be a cost-effective solution for everyone.

4. Difficulty in Weed Management

Landscape fabric can help reduce weed growth, but it’s not a foolproof solution. Weeds can still grow on top of the landscape cloth, and if they do, it can be difficult to remove them.

5. Not Environmentally Friendly

Even the best landscape fabric is usually made from non-biodegradable materials. This means that it can take a long time to break down in landfills and other disposal sites.

Some people even use plastic sheets in their garden beds instead of a layer of fabric, which will take even longer to break down. 

How to Install Landscape Fabric Under Mulch Properly

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

If you are going to install landscape fabric, you’ll want to make sure you do it well so it can be more of a permanent solution.

Before you start the installation process, make sure you have all the necessary tools and materials at hand.

You will need landscape fabric, mulch, garden staples, a measuring tape, scissors, and a rake.

  • Step 1: Measure the area where you want to install the landscape fabric and mulch. Add an extra 6 inches to each side to ensure that the fabric covers the entire area.
  • Step 2: Remove any weeds or debris from the soil and rake the area to make it even.
  • Step 3: Lay the landscape fabric over the soil. Make sure the fabric is positioned flat and taut over the ground. Use garden staples to secure the fabric into place at each corner and along the edges, ensuring that it does not move.
  • Step 4: Cut slits in the landscape fabric where you want to plant any new plants or shrubs. Be careful not to make the cuts too big, as this will allow weeds to grow through.
  • Step 5: Spread mulch over the landscape fabric, making sure it covers the entire area. Mulch should be around 3 inches deep. Use a rake to evenly spread the mulch.
  • Step 6: Water the area to ensure the mulch settles in properly. Avoid over-watering, as this will cause the mulch to move and expose the landscape fabric.
Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

Alternative Options to Landscape Fabric Under Mulch

Landscape fabric under mulch can offer benefits, but it’s not always the best option for every situation. Here are some alternative options to think about:

1. Composting 

Instead of using landscape fabric, you can compost organic material like wood byproducts, leaves, and grass clippings. This will help improve soil health and provide nutrients to plants. These materials are also considered mulch, but you can layer them under your store-bought mulch for more protection.

2. Newspaper or Cardboard

An inexpensive and environmentally-friendly option is to use layers of newspaper or cardboard as a weed barrier. This will eventually break down and add organic matter to the soil.

3. Mulch Only

Some gardeners prefer to skip the use of any type of barrier and simply use a thick layer of wood mulch on bare soil. While weeds may still grow through, the mulch will suppress the growth of weeds and add nutrients to the soil as it decomposes.

4. Chemical Weed Control

Although not the most eco-friendly option, chemical weed control can be effective in preventing weeds from growing under mulch. Be sure to carefully follow the instructions and use only as directed.

When choosing an alternative option, consider your personal preferences, gardening style, and the specific needs of your plants and soil. You want the best choice for your preferences and situation to create the garden or landscaping you want.

What the Experts Recommend

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

When it comes to the debate on using landscape fabric under mulch, many experts have differing opinions.

Some suggest that landscape fabric can be helpful in controlling weeds, while others argue that it can actually cause more harm than good.

The University of Maryland Extension recommends using landscape fabric in areas where it is difficult to control weeds and grasses. They also advise using a minimum of 2-3 inches of mulch on top of the fabric to help prevent it from breaking down and exposing the underlying soil.

On the other hand, the University of Georgia Cooperative Extension suggests avoiding landscape fabric altogether. They argue that it can actually trap moisture, heat, and soil nutrients, which can be harmful to plants and increase the risk of fungal diseases.

Most professionals seem to think that the best way to use landscape fabric is in areas like rock gardens and with the use of small stones. For example, in an area with river rock -where there are no plants, and you don’t have to worry about garden soil, root health, and all that. 

Conclusion

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

Ultimately, the decision to use landscape fabric under a mulch bed should be based on the specific needs of your garden and landscaping.

If you have a serious weed problem or need to protect against soil erosion, using weed block fabric may be a good option. But if you want to promote healthy soil and plant growth, it may be best to skip the fabric and rely on other methods. Alternative methods include hand-weeding or organic mulches like leaves or straw.

As with any landscaping decision, if you need help, you can consult with a professional.

A qualified landscaper or garden expert can provide valuable advice on how to best maintain and improve the health of your plants and soil. They can also offer the best type of approach for your particular needs.

Before you go, here are more posts you’ll enjoy:

Landscape Rock vs Mulch: Which is Better?

Our DIY Raised Garden Bed: A Free Step-by-Step Guide

20 Amazing Health Benefits of Being in Nature

Should I use landscape fabric under mulch?  landscaping tips and alternatives to mulching fabric.

Should I Use Landscape Fabric Under Mulch